The Fifth Book - Theories & News

[matt rider]

Again, after a healthy absence, i'm back (:
I think Jamie will die. Think about it, scott has looked after jamie all his life, and now J is in control. I think he will relish at the chance to finally be able to prove himself and to help his twin when he is in need. I'm a twin myself and it's a closer bond than brother and sister.
Who ever dies, it's sure to be an emotional ride!

[gardenofmoons]

but they will be replaced by their old selves, no? he can't make them die twice? unless it is Jamie cause Sapling already died.. but I will be so sad T___T i thought it would be scarlett because of the way AH ended book 4? @_@

[matt rider]

but they will be replaced by their old selves, no? he can't make them die twice? unless it is Jamie cause Sapling already died.. but I will be so sad T___T i thought it would be scarlett because of the way AH ended book 4? @_@

It could be scar, then past scar may get it on with present jamie.
Anywho, i believe it doesn't work the way you just said. I think Sapling would still replace Jamie, because Jamie only replaced sapling when he was 'dead' so the two worlds work in some sort of parallel.

[gardenofmoons]

but they will be replaced by their old selves, no? he can't make them die twice? unless it is Jamie cause Sapling already died.. but I will be so sad T___T i thought it would be scarlett because of the way AH ended book 4? @_@

It could be scar, then past scar may get it on with present jamie.
Anywho, i believe it doesn't work the way you just said. I think Sapling would still replace Jamie, because Jamie only replaced sapling when he was 'dead' so the two worlds work in some sort of parallel.

Mmk I hope you're right, but I think they would die because I remember Matt I think it was .. saying that "the Old Ones would have to kill us twice" to be able to finally kill them.. so i don't think they're immortal ? *just going by what matt said*

[matt rider]

but they will be replaced by their old selves, no? he can't make them die twice? unless it is Jamie cause Sapling already died.. but I will be so sad T___T i thought it would be scarlett because of the way AH ended book 4? @_@

It could be scar, then past scar may get it on with present jamie.
Anywho, i believe it doesn't work the way you just said. I think Sapling would still replace Jamie, because Jamie only replaced sapling when he was 'dead' so the two worlds work in some sort of parallel.

Mmk I hope you're right, but I think they would die because I remember Matt I think it was .. saying that "the Old Ones would have to kill us twice" to be able to finally kill them.. so i don't think they're immortal ? *just going by what matt said*

Didn't mean immortal, but i just read the series again and it seems more likely that scar would be the one to die, and fall for present Jamie.

[powerof6]

I just want to know when its coming out! its driving me nuts!

[DragonsFlame]

Not for a while AH researched global pollution and warming for a year before he rite Book 4

[kutekates]

Can he please, please, please hurry up I am so desperate to read it already!!!

[MadameLapin]

Hi guys, I've noticed you're all relatively new memebers so welcome ot the board. A few pointers:
Please try and make your posts constructive... preferable 3 sentances or more with something that other people can expand on.
Also, try and make sure spelling and punctuation is correct as there are members of the board who don't have englsih as their first language, so there can be some misunderstandings.
Finally, try and avoid using loads of emoticons/smileys in a post, especially repetition, these are here for fun but nto to be abused.

Sorry to sound harsh, we all make mistakes when we're new.
To reply some of your posts, yes he will take a while becuase AH takes his research seriously, not to mention he has to actually write it. He's already told us there'll be a lot of battles.

[Matt22922]

ML you forgot to mention his estimated 200,000 word count which translates to, in his words, between 800-1000 pages

That should help to put into perspective how this book is going to take a long time to be written. personally i think it will be between a year or 2. hope this helps a bit more

[MadameLapin]

Oh yes *smacks forehead* how silly of me to forget. Yes.... what Matt said xD

Wow... I oculd never imagine writing a book that long. But it makes sense, AH likes his description and with those battles... LOOKS LIKE IT'S GONNA BE A FUN RIDE! But the fun rides of longs lines, we'll have to be patient 

[zakeeyak]

I really don't mind how long I have to wait, as long as when the final product comes out it's packed with great plot, fabulous description, and most of all, a logical and satisfying climax and ending. Knowing AH, I'll probably get my wish, but my biggest fear is that he gets rushed and messes it up. It's happened with so many series that I've read, and if it happens again, I think I might cry. Every time I log on to the board.

[matt rider]

Madame Lapin, sorry but that was ironic when you made like 5 gramatical errors in that speech !

[MadameLapin]

@Zak: Couldn't have put it better myself! He takes his time though, and he laways pleases so I have high hopes.

@Matt: Ironic indeed, but was it really necessary? Especially since you're now off topic. I ckecked my post and my errors were "typos", I've seem them use chat speak before and that is what I meant.

[Matt22922]

I'm sorry if it has been mentioned before but do you think it is possible for Alicia to return?

After re-reading Nightrise i was just wondering what other people thought. I dont think it is that unlikely to happen personally