Necropolis: City of the Dead - Reviews and Discussion (Spoilers Allowed)

[MadCatta]

that may be more suited for the who will die topic....
but oh well, i agree.

BOT

[Power of five girl...!]

oh yeah i know but someone was speaking of how she was dead earlier in this topic and i just really disagreed apologies.

the book ruled though, but i think it could of been better if the friendship between the 4 boys had been developed at start, at least matt n the twins cos they speak same language, but that just me.

[blondest brunette]

Ive hust realised i havnt given my full review of the entire book yet. Well here it is:

I loved Necropolis. It was amazing, the action didnt fully kick in untill about when the Old Ones were chasing Scarlett and Lohan on the roof. And the scenes before that were brillaint, suspensful and well written. After round about the roof scene the book was just fantastic. It was fantasctic, acion packed and brilliant. Necropolis is the best book ive ever read, and ive read quite a lot of books. I cant wait untill book 5
10/10. Fantastic
Well thats my full review

[MadCatta]

  10/10!
i would only give it a 9... and a half...XD

not the best book i've read....

i still think scott needed more...

[gypolord]

yeah definatly. his role in the book ws basically. get attacked freeze. get sperated. randomly come to the resuce at the end of the book. should have been more.

[MadCatta]

i think his was even smaller than pedros....

do we know if scott has actually been to the dreamworld recently? it  said pedro, matt and jamie had, but didnt day if scott was there... (i mean with the others, he did go alone)

[gypolord]

i never understood how pedro suddenly got perfect english. i mean even after 4 months there is no way he would be that good. he was talking like someone who uses english as a first language

[dj26792]

with a good teacher and consistent hard work he could get there, some people are just good at learning languages.
also he wasnt using complicated words, english at the level of most teenagers wouldnt be hard to manage if you heard it a lot while you were learning English.  also his accent may have been atrocious, we dont know

[Pedro-ologist]

TALK ABOUT SCOTT! this was pedro's big chance and he did not do ANYTHING!!!!!

apart from weather control (yes you prooved my theory wrong) none of the theorys were correct...really, it seems that scar is not looking for love so there will be no love story, it helps to know about 3 of the five now (as scott and pedro still were not described) now some more theorys will come into play and every one will be happy until the 5th book comes out and they are prooven wrong

[edgauw]

true, i actually just realise, scott's role so far has been REALLY REALLY SMALL, even in nightrise, where it supposedly about the twins. but scott is always 'away' in both book. okay, in nightrise, scott is abducted and tortured. now, in necro, scott is told to stay in vilcabamba.. --". i want pedro's and scott's roles more!! 

[MadCatta]

pedros roles were fine... until necro at least but he has about twice as much as scott altogether.... NEED MORE SCOTT

[gypolord]

book five should be about scott. all the others got books for themselves

[Pedro-ologist]

3/4 of scott the rest for pedro but it is being writen in 5 parts, on of each the gatekeepers.

OMG Necropolis was sooooo good best PO5 book so far!!!

[Rocket]

Necro was great1 And Scar is the best! And what was so funny was that everyone was runnning around in circles to find each other

[MadCatta]

i dont like scar so much......

and that was ironic and predictable... but good