Who will die?? ( The Five and Other)

[gatekeeper96]

that would bw a pretty sad -but great- ending or where ever it would be put in hte story

[bigmac]

i think matt will die because he is like the leader and seems like he would put himself before the others... try 2 protect pedro, not want to split scott and jamie up, and i think he might like scarllet maybe and want her not to die so yeah. and the old matt knew everything so he might just think it would be better for him to die and them get help from the other matt

[Rayray. M]

I was thinking the other day and i  have come to the conclusion that Scot will die. It makes sense! He will pretend to be Jamie and get killed and then the old ones will think they killed jamie twice so they've won but it was actually scot so flint will come to the furture and they'll lose and the five will win! Of course I think maybe two people will die so possibly matt will die too...

[gatekeeper96]

oh my god. i never thought of that. that's a really good idea. then flint will come back and there would still be the five of them.

[bigmac]

tht is good. but wat advantage does flint give to the five?
not to like question u thts really good

[Rayray. M]

Haha being questioned is good, it makes me think more. I think flint would give them an advantage because he was in the last battle and would be experienced in running an army and i think he knows more that they do at the moment, because past Matt said to Jamie before he left that he'd explain everything to Scar Flint and Inti so they probably know a lot of what he knows by now, maybe not it all but a lot of it. Plus if two die and the second one to die is Matt then they'd have past Matt who seems like a incredible leader capable of gaining them a lot of followers willing to fight for them even though they're just teenagers.

[bigmac]

ok tht makes sense but i dont think he would know how to beat them yet because it would take him from the past before he learned the stuff... and i still want to know who the past mat really was....
and yes i no theres another page 4 tht

[lupo_jerico]

Haha being questioned is good, it makes me think more. I think flint would give them an advantage because he was in the last battle and would be experienced in running an army and i think he knows more that they do at the moment, because past Matt said to Jamie before he left that he'd explain everything to Scar Flint and Inti so they probably know a lot of what he knows by now, maybe not it all but a lot of it. Plus if two die and the second one to die is Matt then they'd have past Matt who seems like a incredible leader capable of gaining them a lot of followers willing to fight for them even though they're just teenagers.

i dont think matt is going to die i will either say scott or scarlett will die but with the matt thing...i actually think matt will just gain the memories (sorry if i miss spell anything)  of old  matt or something like that... and also i think the person who wrote the books in the dream world library is the old matt just to say.... thanks for listening to me. =)

[Rayray. M]

ok tht makes sense but i dont think he would know how to beat them yet because it would take him from the past before he learned the stuff... and i still want to know who the past mat really was....
and yes i no theres another page 4 tht

You could be right about him being taken before he has the knowledge but him coming to the future would explain how he got the knowledge and why he calls himself Matt and not whatever his real name is.
Sadly we wont have answers for an estimated three years when the next book will be out...
And Lupo_Jerico i think thats an interesting Idea about the librarian being old matt. But how exactly would that work might i ask? Oh and Welcome to the board! Here's to hoping you enjoy chatting with everyone here and make a few good friends

[lupo_jerico]

Well my idea was that since past Matt knows alot about alot he must be able to see far into the future or his power is so strong that he can see anyting in the future.... and well he said that they spent alot of time in the library in the past dream world because that's where they found the past scar... if i remember correctly and well if they can make the gates to seal away the old ones and make all of the doors they must have the power to travel around in the dream world (like the librarian said there are doors in the dream world too) just because the old ones threat was over after that battle do sent mean they were not able to go back to the dream world after the old ones were put away...so i am guessing past Matt probably spent alot of time in the library afterword so he can write down the events of what happened... its just my opinion though. (any one have any other ideas?)

[MadCatta]

@Bigmac: Hun, the two of us know that you've been reminded of this a lot. Please stop with the chat speak... Even me, English being my first language, on four hours of sleep meant it took me five minutes to understand this:

and yes i no theres another page 4 tht

It's really off putting and annoying to have to decipher the posts.

@Lupo: I don't think we've "met" yet, so welcome xD and hope you enjoy the board. And if we have, well, sorry.. I've got a bad memory.

So you think Past Matt knows what happens to Present Matt and everyone? And then... something which went RIGHT over my head and then he wrote everything down? Like Matt writing most/all of the books in the library? Hmmm... could work....

And we had the Scott-being-Jamie-to-get-killed discussion quite a while ago, and basically we kinda thought that it wasn't really what Flint would bring... it was more that well, for one it would mean the Old Ones would think Jamie died altogether, including Sapling and if maybe Scott actually wasn't able to fight 'cause of his whole condition, that Flint would just be a reliable version of Scott. And the whole fought-in-the-past thing.

[lupo_jerico]

well  you have not met me yet so hi back! =) and well i was thinking about the library thing and it could work since the past matt could of lived for a long time after that battle he could of lived till he was like 100 for all we know so that gives him plenty of time to write the books and his powers probably could of grown alot more as he got older...

[Cat Lover]

Dos anyone think one of the five will kill another? i had a theorie that some one else finds the library in the dreamworld and read ones of the fives books as see that they turn evil so kill them to bring the good one back form the past?

Personally i think Jamie find the library and the librarian is there and tellshim to read Scott's book. He reads that the Old Ones get controle of him from the stuff that happened in Scilent Creek. When he wakes Hes all-i don't upset?-and has this mental battel for a few days like Save Scott or the world. Then he decides to save the world and has the kill Scott. Matt and the other five run in and are all like "what happened?" and get real mad at Jamie then Jamie shouts "I read his book" and then Matt understands. Well you get the idea. (I hope)

Then Flint comes back with a message for Matt from past Matt.

Just my theorie

[gatekeeper96]

i kinda get it, but what kind of message would past matt have

[Cat Lover]

I don't know probly something really criptic like:
"go where the sun never sets" or "trust in trees" or some thing realy wack that makes no sence whatsoever until it's actualy happening